What If I’m Right
The story behind What If I’m Right is very dark, very sinister. It’s about relapsing with alcohol addiction. Josephine told the full story on her podcast. In case you want to listen, the episode is down here.
“I experimented with some piano and strings but eventually I went with a fully a cappella version because it best represents the overwhelming loneliness I felt in knowing something no one was allowed to know.”
This song showcases Josephine’s raw, emotional lyricism, with a cold opening that gives you goosebumps right from the start. Her soft, warm vocals and comforting harmonies feel like a warm hug in a harsh reality.
Behind the song
My parents used to drink a lot. My mom had an alcohol addiction. They didn’t get along which I didn’t understand as a kid. My sister told me that my dad became disabled after a failed back surgery, which left him in constant pain. This forced my mom to go from being a stay-at-home mom to working full-time to support us, putting immense pressure on her. My sister said my mom had an affair, which he was never able to forgive.
Their fights were intense and terrifying, with screaming and physical altercations. Sometimes, we had to stay with our neighbors or grandparents until the police came to take our parents away. No one in our family talked about it. My mom dismissed it as normal couple arguments. This led to my sister and I growing up pretty isolated. At (primary) school I used to worry a lot about my parents wellbeing.
During high school there were still many fights, mostly verbal. When I was 16, their final physical fight occured, I go more in depth in the podcast episode, I prefer to not do that here.
There were numerous relapses including alcohol combined with morphine or codeine.
I remember feeling like I couldn’t confide in my parents about anything I was going through at school because home wasn’t a safe place for me. So I would keep everything that happened at school to myself as well.
Apart from this situation my parents still tried their best for us. They always tried to make sure we didn’t have to miss out on anything because of financial difficulties, like school trips, music classes.
My childhood wasn’t black and white. There were many beautiful moments too.
Lyrics
What if I’m right and we were a lie all along
Cause you knew my feelings
But went and choose booze over it all
What if I’m worthy of the love you neglected me
When I was just a little kid
Cause you didn’t have time for me
Don’t have the right to take away
My potential, my mental state
Just because you couldn’t keep control
Oh I’m gonna be honest
If history repeats itself
I’m not sure I can help you
I’m not equipped to deal with this
I don’t know how I’ll react
When our past hits chapter two
Cause that would mean that
Everything we’ve been through
Wasn’t true
Boy I’m tryna slip my mind
But it just keeps catching up with me
And breathing is a have to do
Cause it’s just getting heavier for me
Swimming against all the odds
I’m drowning, it’s just not enough
I’m thinking that the way I’m treating me
Is not good
Oh I’m gonna be honest
If history repeats itself
I’m not sure I can help you
I’m not equipped to deal with this
I don’t know how I’ll react
When our past hits chapter two
Cause that would mean that
Everything we’ve been through
Wasn’t true
Swimming against all the odds
I’m drowning, it’s never enough
I’m thinking that the way I’m treating me
Is not good at all
Likely to be sinking down
I try to turn it all around
I’m facing a choice between my life or yours
I’m going overboard
Oh I’m gonna be honest
If history repeats itself
I’m not sure I can help you
I’m not equipped to deal with this
I don’t know how I’ll react
When our past hits chapter two
Cause that would mean that
Everything we’ve been through
Wasn’t true